European Union |Analysis

Could Ireland stop Brexit in its tracks?

  1. Open border is crucial to peace in Northern Ireland
  2. Dublin could take a last chance to stall Brexit
  3. Northern Ireland without a provincial government

Talk (2)

Angela Long

Angela Long

"I thought it was true, Alain, as Bert..."
AD

ALAIN DUBOIS

"Sorry but I don't think that it is tr..."
Irish and British flags fly together, with the EU flag in the background. Image: alphawealth

“You’ll never beat the Irish” is the song that fans like to sing at international sporting matches involving the Republic of Ireland. Sometimes it ends up being ironic, but the cheerful spirit of the fans is resilient. However, Brexit threatens to beat the Irish in a number of ways, as Northern Ireland leaves the EU and the so-called six counties in the north of the island of Ireland become foreign territory.

But could the Irish veto the whole process at an EU meeting in mid-December?

At the EU Council in Brussels on December 14-15, a vote will be taken on progress so far in the negotiations between the UK and the remaining 27 EU members.

At this meeting, any EU state can stymie moving forward. But at subsequent meetings, the Qualified Majority Voting (QMV) system will ensure that no single country has a veto. It means there’s a critical last chance for Ireland to force the issue of the open borders it wants to retain with the north — to keep border trade open but also the free movement of goods and people central to the accords which ended decades of sectarian unrest.

Academic and journalist Paul Gillespie told WikiTribune: “It is as fine a call as any in the history of Irish foreign policy.”

As in any situation involving the Irish Republic and the northern counties which form part of the United Kingdom, the shadow of the Troubles, the years of sectarian discord between nationalist and unionist, Catholic and Protestant, is not far away.

Ireland determined to keep border open

If Ireland feels that issues surrounding its border with Northern Ireland have not been cleared up, it could in theory vote against. The former prime minister, Bertie Ahern,  in a speech to the British-Irish Chamber of Commerce, reported in The Irish Times, warned that Irish influence over the Brexit negotiations will wane after the December European Council gathering. And the plain-spoken former leader, who co-signed the Good Friday Agreement with Tony Blair in 1998, observed that if anyone “expects that when it comes to the cold light of day on trade issues that the EU 27 will break up over anything that is do with us, well, Christmas isn’t coming this year, folks”.

More fighting words came from the Irish Foreign Affairs Minister, Simon Coveney, interviewed by London newspaper the Evening Standard.

After Mrs May doubled her proposed “divorce settlement” to €40 billion, Mr Coveney said that this should not be enough to ensure acceptance of the British offer. The UK Prime Minister would also have to address the Irish border question. He said: “Anybody who thinks that just because the financial settlement issue gets resolved . . . that somehow Ireland will have a hand put on the shoulder and be told, ‘Look, it’s time to move on.’ Well, we’re not going to move on.”

“Anyone who thinks that it can be a closed border does not know the border. Neither President Trump nor even Benjamin Netanyahu could build a wall along it.”

– Lord Cope of Berkeley, Hansard, UK House of Lords, September 2017

Map showing the border around the six counties which make up Northern Ireland, in yellow. Image: Wikipedia

At the core of the issue is the openness of the border between the two parts of the island of Ireland, and the complexity of that border, writes WikiTribune contributor Jonathan Cardy. The border, which runs for 310 miles (500km), follows historic county lines, which predate even the road system. In the past when the border was enforced many minor crossings were closed in order to make the border manageable. This involved inconveniences that many who live near the border are loath to see resumed. In recent decades the border has been completely open, both for trade (with the UK and the Republic of Ireland in the same trading bloc), and also for travel.  The UK and Ireland have very similar rules as to who can live, visit or work in their countries.

London has apparently contradictory aims

However,  the UK’s vote for Brexit is likely to mean that the UK will no longer be in the same trading bloc as Ireland. Meanwhile, the UK government’s wish to “take control” of its border and cut down on immigration from Eastern Europe is widely seen as incompatible with keeping an open border with an Irish Republic that has no restrictions on migration from the other 26 EU countries.

In Theresa May’s so-called Florence speech in September she committed both that “we will not accept any physical infrastructure at the border” and also that “it will take time to put in place the new immigration system required to re-take control of the UK’s borders”.

It shouldn’t surprise anyone that the Irish government will be keen to see how she plans to reconcile such apparently contradictory statements before it lets the negotiations go beyond the point where Dublin can exercise a veto. Mrs May’s problem is that with her government dependent on Northern Ireland’s Democratic Unionist Party to survive, it may not be possible for her to reconcile those statements and continue to hold her coalition together.

Complicating everything is the effective suspension of the local political assembly in Northern Ireland, which has lasted most of 2017, as The Economist magazine summarises.

International news agency Bloomberg wondered whether Ireland was hurtling towards a veto which would have the effect of halting the Brexit negotiations. Paul Gillespie, a veteran observer of all things EU, expressed his concerns in this column, ‘Should Ireland fear a perfidious Albion?’

Peace process seen at risk

Former Irish Justice Minister, Alan Shatter, stated his view in a letter to The Irish Times, the Irish “paper of record“. He wrote: “It is politically important to do everything necessary to force the UK Brexiteers to confront reality and the UK government discuss what arrangements it is proposing to ensure we do not return to past divisions on this island and do anything that could act as a catalyst to the resumption of sectarian violence. However, we also need to ensure we do not lose sight of the importance Northern unionists attach to their British identity and the impact of flags and symbols on our island.”

London law firm Doughty Street published a thorough analysis of the issues affecting Northern Ireland, with special attention to the Good Friday Agreement (GFA) and the possible alternatives of ‘special status’ for the six counties in the north. Authors Caoilfhionn Gallagher and Katherine O’Byrne wrote: “Of all the complex political and legal problems facing the UK and Europe in advance of the UK’s exit from the European Union in March 2019, its potential impact on Northern Ireland is undoubtedly the most difficult.”

Noting that the Good Friday Agreement “includes multiple provisions for implementation of EU policies and programmes”, the authors conclude that the UK’s withdrawal from the EU, as it stands, “is not compatible with the GFA in all its parts” (their italics).

Complicating all of this was the Irish government being poised on a knife-edge in late November, with only a fortnight until the key EU meeting. A long-running controversy over attempts by the national police force to discredit a whistle-blower culminated with an opposition motion of no confidence in the deputy prime minister (Tánaiste), Frances Fitzgerald. Feverish talk of a pre-Christmas election – and a lame-duck administration talking to the EU – was defused when Ms Fitzgerald resigned, as The Irish Times reported.

The chance remains that Ireland could and would use its veto, its last opportunity to derail the progress of Brexit.


Started by

Consulting editor with WikiTribune. Previous career mostly in print media, news and feature writer, commissioning editor, copy editor, trainer and teacher. 25+ years in leading European/British media, BBC, FT, Sunday Times, Irish Times, including five years on latter's foreign desk. Launch team, Open Government Partnership, Dublin 2013. Teach digital media ethics and journalism practice.

History for stories "Could Ireland stop Brexit in its tracks?"

Select two items to compare revisions

30 November 2017

16:08:49, 30 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → removing 'next month')
16:07:58, 30 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → counties not provinces!)
15:59:17, 30 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → inserting map showing border)

29 November 2017

16:29:21, 29 Nov 2017 . .‎ Dominik Arncken (Updated → removed double space "Dublin can exercise a veto")

28 November 2017

14:17:35, 28 Nov 2017 . .‎ Peter Bale (Updated → Shortened highlights)
12:40:29, 28 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → )
12:37:40, 28 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → )
12:36:59, 28 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → updating Irish election prospect)
12:15:50, 28 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → adding Shatter link, blurring election decision)

27 November 2017

17:48:29, 27 Nov 2017 . .‎ Peter Bale (Updated → )
17:46:06, 27 Nov 2017 . .‎ Peter Bale (Updated → )
17:45:12, 27 Nov 2017 . .‎ Peter Bale (Updated → Minor edits)
14:35:12, 27 Nov 2017 . .‎ Harry Ridgewell (Updated → fixing formatting)
14:30:07, 27 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → )
14:25:13, 27 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → )
13:48:57, 27 Nov 2017 . .‎ Burhan Wazir (Updated → editing)
12:52:05, 27 Nov 2017 . .‎ George Engels (Updated → added thumbnail)
09:33:40, 27 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → )
09:27:09, 27 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → )
09:24:45, 27 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → )
09:23:25, 27 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → Gillespie column link)
09:21:30, 27 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → )
09:15:53, 27 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → Bloomberg link)
09:14:24, 27 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → adding Irish election possible at end)
09:07:48, 27 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → cutting out waiting notes)

23 November 2017

16:26:19, 23 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → paul g info)
16:01:09, 23 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → )
15:53:52, 23 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → adding Doughty St quotes)
13:03:57, 23 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → Doughty St link)
12:57:35, 23 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → adding Economist link)
12:55:37, 23 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → )
12:53:42, 23 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → copy tidying JC's contribution)
12:52:27, 23 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → taking one 'border' out of sentence)

22 November 2017

16:38:36, 22 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → )
16:32:41, 22 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → )
16:30:37, 22 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → )
16:29:03, 22 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → adding Lord Cope)
16:13:36, 22 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → notes for self)
16:06:22, 22 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → finishing Coveney quote)
16:02:24, 22 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → should have been private)
15:44:48, 22 Nov 2017 . .‎ Jonathan Cardy (Updated → expand)
15:41:22, 22 Nov 2017 . .‎ Jonathan Cardy (Updated → )
15:27:51, 22 Nov 2017 . .‎ Jonathan Cardy (Updated → expand detail re border)
15:01:05, 22 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → )
14:59:42, 22 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → )
14:57:17, 22 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → )
14:55:05, 22 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → putting in links)
14:48:51, 22 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → )
14:45:25, 22 Nov 2017 . .‎ Angela Long (Updated → )

Talk for Story "Could Ireland stop Brexit in its tracks?"

Talk about this Story

  1. Rewrite

    I thought it was true, Alain, as Bertie Ahern warned (mentioned in the piece). Also Paul Gillespie who is an absolute expert. Any member of the EU can vote against continuing Brexit negotiations at the December summit. It’s mentioned also in this BBC piece, which quotes the Irish foreign minister as saying he doesn’t want to veto but ….
    https://www.independent.ie/irish-news/politics/ireland-does-not-want-to-veto-brexit-talks-coveney-tells-bbc-36374339.html
    However … if there is a clear reference you could provide from EU sources it would be very welcome to get this right.

  2. Rewrite

    Sorry but I don’t think that it is true that Ireland has a legal right to block phase one of the negotiations. Everything concerning article 50 is at qualified majority of the council. It is only because the 27 countries, and especially France and Germany, agree to support Ireland that Ireland has such power.

    Politically, it is however true that now is a better time to push their agenda than later. Because the EU has decided that the irish border was one of the 3 topics that have to be agreed before going to phase 2 of the negotiations. If they pass on this, the further negotiations will have so many topics that their specific issue risk at being seen as minor.

Subscribe to our newsletter to receive news, alerts and updates

Support Us

Why this is important and why you should care about facts, journalism and democracy

WikiTribune Open menu Close Search Like Previous page Next page Back Next Open menu Close menu Play video RSS Feed Share on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Follow us on Youtube Connect with us on Linkedin Email us Message us on Facebook Messenger Save for Later