United States |Developing

Developing: Facebook addresses Russian involvement in US elections

Talk (4)

Charles Turner

Charles Turner

"Hi Todd, Are there any defined so..."
Todd Grotenhuis

Todd Grotenhuis

"_Weapons of Math Destruction_ has a g..."

Clive Tabraham

"I agree. We'll see how long my change..."
Jimmy Wales

Jimmy Wales

"The headline "meddling" doesn't strik..."

On Monday, Facebook handed the details of 3,000 advertisements, which were found to have links to Russian-state actors, to members of the United States Congress.

It is gradually being discovered that the Kremlin used Facebook as a medium to build electoral support for Donald J. Trump for the 2016 presidential election.

The ads in question did not directly focus on former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, instead it appears that the messaging was geared at widening the racial divides of the US, reports the Washington Post. The social movement Black Lives Matter, for example, was a common theme of the Russian advertising campaign.

Specifics of these Russian-linked ads were not available to the public. Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg was initially reluctant to release details to Congress after cooperating with special counsel Robert Muller, reports Bloomberg. But on Thursday, Zuckerberg announced on Facebook Live that the social network would include elected officials into the discussion.

“I care deeply about the democratic process and protecting its integrity. I don’t want anyone to use our tools to undermine our democracy,” Zuckerberg said in a prepared statement on September 21.

The New York Times reports that since July Facebook has taken down 470 fake profiles and pages after it was discovered that they were linked to a Russian company known to work with the Kremlin. The pages had made over $100,000 worth of ad purchases which focused on deepening divides on subjects such as race, religion, and LGBT issues.

End Of Targeting Ads?

A panel of advertising consultants at the Advertising Week New York, an annual trade conference, speculated that Facebook will likely impose regulations on political advertisements going forward, as reported by Reuters.

Facebook and Google made up 20 percent of global advertising revenue last year, with Facebook bringing in $26.9 billion, according to media agency Zenith.

Zuckerberg has committed to monitoring advertisements associated with elections. The same Reuters report states that Facebook has plans to make political ads visible to all users of the platform, removing the ability of political campaigns to reach only relevant audiences.

Facebook has pioneered the concept of targeted advertisements. Based off of Facebook profile details, the buyer of an ad is able to select which demographics can see their post. This is useful for political campaigns that are interested in “finding” voters – the tagline for Facebook’s political advertising arm.

Examples Of Russian-Backed Facebook Pages and Profiles

  • Being Patriotic: Taken down in August, this page had over 200,000 followers and even organized in-person rallies, as reported by The Daily Beast.
  • Secured Borders: Taken down in August, this page focused on Muslim refugees in the United States. The Kremlin-linked page also tried to mobilize the town of Twin Falls, Idaho against recently resettled Muslim families in the state, as reported by the New York Times.

Started by

United States
Charles Michio Turner is an American journalist who reports on labor, politics and development. In 2016, he reported from Myanmar on the several growing social movements in the country. His goal is to find new ways to include audiences in the new reporting process. Let him know if there's an issue or question that you see as being underreported or poorly reported. Twitter: @charlesmichio

History for stories "Developing: Facebook addresses Russian involvement in US elections"

Select two items to compare revisions

21 May 2018

• (view) . . Comment: Irish emigrants travel home in effort to sway abortion referendum‎; 13:08:33, 21 May 2018 . . Lydia Morrish (talk | contribs)‎‎ ( Comment -> Hey Dan, a caption has been added into the story – it is at the end in "sources and references". )

12 January 2018

05 January 2018

Talk for Story "Developing: Facebook addresses Russian involvement in US elections"

Talk about this Story

  1. Other

    _Weapons of Math Destruction_ has a great exploration of microtargeting and news, as well as some interesting stats.

    One of the biggest challenges around this is “opacity”. When we get microtargeted social media, we can’t debate its merits, because we can’t see what other people are seeing. A huge challenge here is even defining what is “political” because these actors can get around the strict-political definition by targeting emotional social topics that are _related_ to politics, and have a similar effect. Targeting “political” ads may not be enough, and the whole system may need to be examined.

    From the book:

    * “In other words, Facebook’s algorithms can affect how millions of people feel, and those people won’t know that it’s happening. What would occur if they played with people’s emotions on Election Day?” p 184 (62% of folks didn’t realize that Facebook tinkers with news feed)
    * “Those results [from a Google-style test], they said, shifted voting preferences by 20 percent.” p. 184 (73% think search results impartial)
    * “each [message] allows candidates to quietly sell multiple versions of themselves—and it’s anyone’s guess which version will show up for work after inauguration.” p. 188

    1. Rewrite

      Hi Todd,

      Are there any defined solutions of how to reform micro targeting? I’d be interested in learning about alternative models.


  2. Rewrite

    The headline “meddling” doesn’t strike me as the most neutral possible headline.

    1. I agree. We’ll see how long my change lasts.

Subscribe to our newsletter and be the first to collaborate on our developing stories:

Support Us

Why this is important and why you should care about facts, journalism and democracy

WikiTribune Open menu Close Search Like Previous page Next page Back Next Open menu Close menu Play video RSS Feed Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Reddit Follow us on Instagram Follow us on Youtube Connect with us on Linkedin Email us Message us on Facebook Messenger Save for Later