magnifying glass

WikiTribune's fact checking guidelines


       Choosing Claims

  • Choose empirically provable claims. If it’s not empirically provable, it isn’t fact-checking. To illustrate, we can check number of women in the U.S. Congress or the location of the school in Florida where the mass shooting took place, or if someone said a particular statement in a recorded and published speech. By contrast, we can’t check what the same person implied by his or her statement.
  • Focus more on claims which have received attention such as viral news stories and tweets.

        Laying out the page

  • Cite the claim properly, always link to the source of the claim.
  • When fact-checking quotes, or when attributing a claim to a person, always quote the person verbatim, in addition to having a link to the source of the claim.

      Correction of Errors

  • WikiTribune is a wiki, meaning that mistakes will be made, but they can also be undone/fixed!
  • If you see a mistake, first consider fixing it yourself.
  • If you don’t feel comfortable fixing it yourself, let others know on the TALK page.

      Role of Community and Editors

  • Community is at the heart of WT fact-checking. This is a collaborative effort by the group.
  • If there is a dispute, remember to seek consensus on the TALK page before making big changes.
  • Trusted users and staff administrators may at times be called upon to judge the veracity of a claim, or to judge community consensus. (This is similar to the role of administrators in Wikipedia RfCs.)

    The right to reply

  • An essential part of the process is to give people a right to reply when we fact check their claims. This gives them the opportunity to clarify and add more information about their stated claim(s). We do this by first sending a direct email to the person and also asking them to write directly on the article’s TALK page.

   This is an evolving document!

  • As a wiki, nothing is ever done! This is the first draft of the fact-checking guidelines, but please, be bold, if you see something wrong, change something!
  • Share
    Share

Subscribe to our newsletter and be the first to collaborate on our developing articles:

WikiTribune Open menu Close Search Like Back Next Open menu Close menu Play video RSS Feed Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Reddit Follow us on Instagram Follow us on Youtube Connect with us on Linkedin Email us